The Columbusite Devours New York City! A Food Guide to Three Days in The Big Apple

If you’ve been keeping up with us on social media you may be aware that we recently accompanied a small group of Columbus State University donors and staff on a pilgrimage to New York to attend the American premiere of Wünderkind, Claudia Müller’s new documentary on our very own Carson McCullers. That event will get a story of its own. This one is about what we ate! 

As someone who primarily writes the food articles ‘round these parts, you could correctly assume that my favorite part of planning a trip is choosing where to eat. The following list is half pre-researched and planned, must visit establishments and a few that were chosen in more of a fly by the seat of your pants, “wow, if I don’t eat something right this second I may perish,” kind of way. Spoiler alert, everything we landed on was great. So if you ever have three days in NYC and don’t want to spend a lot of time hemming and hawing over the estimated 48,960 restaurants to choose from, here are some of our top recommendations. 

Day 1: Touchdown in NYC – Ramen, British Charm, and Allure

Lunch at Kyuramen  

If, like us, you didn’t have time for breakfast, order yourselves a variety of appetizers to share while you wait for the main event. We had pan fried gyoza, chili garlic edamame, and Ika Geso Kara-Age (deep fried squid with lemon). All delicious. 

As far as the ramen goes, you really can’t go wrong. There's enough variety on the menu to suit many taste buds, but I was in the mood for something rich and comforting that was also invigoratingly spicy. The Korean Kimchi Ramen satisfied both desires. It’s served with, chashu pork, kimchi, half marinated egg, bamboo shoots, corn, wakame, scallion, and nori in a spicy pork broth.

Dinner at Lillie’s Victorian Establishment

For dinner, make a reservation at Lillie’s Victorian just off Times Square. The intricate decor feels like stepping into the most elaborately decorated ball scenes in an episode of Bridgerton. I love it when restaurants really commit to a theme. If you’re going to do it, go all the way!

Aside from the fantastical environment, you can expect a pretty fabulous dinner. We tried the smoked duck breast that was served with parsnip puree, maple glazed brussel sprouts, cherry tomato confit & red wine reduction and lobster ravioli in a creamy tomato based sauce & freshly grated parmesan cheese. 

They have a fabulous cocktail menu that includes non alcoholic options, bar bites, sandwiches, and salads as well so there is something for everybody to enjoy. 

---

Day 2: Artisanal Flavors and Brooklyn’s Eclectic Vibes

Breakfast at Pavé Café  

Kick off your day with breakfast at Pave Café, known for its quality pastries and coffee. Their almond croissants and strong coffee will fuel you for a day of exploring. It’s a charming and relaxed spot to ease into the morning.

Lunch at Queen in Brooklyn

Take the subway to Brooklyn for lunch at Queen, a Mediterranean-inspired spot in Bushwick with fresh, inventive dishes. The flavors here are bright and bold, with a focus on local ingredients and unique spices. Order a mix of mezze and a main, like lamb with tahini or roasted vegetables, for a full experience.

Afternoon Pick-Me-Up at Wyckoff Starr Coffee Shop  

After lunch, get your caffeine fix at Wyckoff Starr Coffee Shop, known for its quirky Twin Peaks theme. Grab a “damn good coffee” and enjoy.

Dinner at Nom Wah Tea Parlor

Make your way to Chinatown for dinner at Nom Wah Tea Parlor, an NYC institution since the 1920s. This historic dim sum spot is beloved for its dumplings, scallion pancakes, and classic Chinese dishes. I’ll tell you now, this was my favorite eating experience of the trip and I think you should definitely make a point to go if you like dim sum or want to try it. It’s a famous place for a reason. 

---

Day 3: Art and Sophistication to End the Trip

Coffee and Croissant from a Cart outside The Met  

On your final day, grab a classic New York breakfast—a coffee and a croissant from one of the city’s iconic carts near The Met. It’s simple, tasty, and lets you savor the moment before exploring the museum.

Lunch at The Met Dining Room  

After a morning at The Met, treat yourself to lunch in the members-only dining room. With views overlooking Central Park and a refined, seasonal menu, it’s a serene way to enjoy an elevated meal amidst the city’s bustle. If you're fortunate enough to get a reservation, try a fresh salad or seasonal entrée while taking in the gorgeous view. Under no circumstances are you to skip dessert. 

Dinner at The Elgin  

Wrap up your trip with dinner at The Elgin in Midtown. This classic bar and grill has a warm, inviting ambiance with a great selection of cocktails, wines, and comfort foods. Go for the Vodka Pizza which has soppressata, vodka sauce, arugula, honey, crushed chillies, and fennel pollen and the Elgin Chopped Salad avocado, israeli couscous, corn, watercress, pepitas, currants, tomato, ricotta salata, basil ranch. Choose something nice off the drinks menu and raise a glass to three unforgettable days in NYC!